Appeals Court Case of Former Commissioner John West and County Clerk Scheduled
An oral argument has been scheduled for March 5th by the Oregon Court of Appeals in former Commissioner John West's case against County Clerk Rhiannon Henkels.
The Daily Courier reports that, three weeks before the recall election against West, he filed a complaint in Josephine County Circuit Court asking a judge to declare the recall petition void and block the election.
He argued the statistical sampling method that Henkels used to verify that petitioners had turned in enough valid signatures to trigger the election was wrong, and she should have verified every signature. He also asked for a temporary restraining order prohibiting her from conducting the election.
On December 4th, 2024, Henkels responded that the sampling method was carried out according to state law and administrative rules, which reportedly tell clerks to use statistical sampling.
West amended the complaint in a court filing December 16th, 2024, the day before the election was to take place. The amended complaint also asked the judge to declare the election void.
The day after the election, attorneys for West and Henkels argued the case before Circuit Court Judge Robert S. Bain. He ruled in favor of Henkels on January 6th, 2025, dismissing the case with prejudice, meaning it cannot be refiled. However, it can be appealed, which West filed notice he was doing on February 7th of that year.
Posted on 1/21/26 1:10PM by Alex Bauer